Does broadcast or participation matter more in the life of faith?
Do Minutes Matter?
One of the areas of vast difference for preachers is the length of their sermons. While there is a lot of variety in local pulpits, most of the largest pulpits in non-denominational and evangelical traditions have preachers who go on for 40 minutes or more. While this is common in BIPOC church traditions, I’m struck by the differences between mainline (my own tradition) and evangelical ones on the length of the sermon.
Does it matter? It might. One of my church members (who came from an evangelical tradition with longer sermons) framed the importance of longer messaging in this way:
Everyone has exposure to ads and messages that are not from the Gospel assaulting your senses for minutes or hours each day. Why shouldn’t we be filling the airwaves with Gospel messages that give life to balance out those that don’t?
My church member suggested considering the differences between mega-church and mainline worship services to see if sermon length has an impact. Let’s do that now.
Mainline v. Megachurch Minutes
Let’s compare a local megachurch service with my local mainline church, comparing both the length of the sermon and the frequency of attendance.
I’m located in the Pacific Northwest, where according to Pew Research’s Religious Landscape study, church attendance is about 50% one-to-two times a month and 50% weekly.
The megachurch average congregant receives the following minutes of broadcast content in a month, divided by attendance:
- Sermon each Sunday: 40 minutes
- Midweek podcast/teaching: 20 minutes.
- TOTAL amount of broadcast content for a four-week month: 240 minutes (weekly attendance), 120 minutes (biweekly)
Mainline church average congregant:
- Sermon each Sunday: 20 minutes
- Midweek podcast/teaching: None.
- TOTAL amount of broadcast content for a month: 80 minutes (weekly attendance), 40 minutes (biweekly)
That’s a vast difference! But what does it mean?
The “Air War”
Disgraced former Pacific Northwest pastor Mark Driscoll used to call this disparity the “air war” where the church needed to fill more of the week with their own messaging so that their members and listeners do not fill their heads with the wrong type of content–which, to him, came from other churches (like mine), but we can be charitable and say secular messaging.
Whatever you think of that framework, the comparison in the section above shows the strategy is effective in comparison. The typical megachurch offers three times more exposure to their broadcasts of theology and guidance. And the disparity can be vast: a weekly megachurcher receives twelve (12!) times the amount of religious guidance of a once-a-month mainliner.
Woof. I can see the appeal to longer broadcasted sermons: the numbers show that it wins the “air war” for sure.
Is the Broadcast the most important?
That said, worship is not just broadcasting of theology and guidance: it also includes other elements with different purposes, chosen by the worship leadership. While evangelical megachurches may fill the worship service with sermon, prayer, and music, more liturgical mainline churches fill their time with other touchstones of the faith, and that difference is stark as well.
Let’s compare these two local services again but look beyond the sermon. The typical 70-minute megachurch experience can be timed out to:
- 40 minutes of sermon (including scripture usually read during the sermon)
- 20 minutes of contemporary praise music (all written after 2000)
- 10 minutes of prayer by the worship leader and the benediction
A liturgical 70-minute mainline worship (using my local church as an example) is usually:
- 20 minutes of sermon
- 5 minutes of introducing and reading Scripture
- 5 minutes of Prayers of the People
- 10 minutes of hymns (all written between 1400 and 2001)
- 5 minutes special music (choral and soloist)
- 15 minutes for weekly Holy Communion liturgy and service
- 5 minutes passing of the peace & announcements
- 5 minutes of liturgy (call to worship, opening prayer, liturgical responses, sending forth liturgy, often from scripture)
So in the 70 minutes of worship, put into the typology of United Methodism, the mainline congregation gets at least:
- 20 minutes of Reason: Sermon placing the Gospel in a logical, persuasive construct that draws from the other sources, of course.
- 30 minutes of participating in Tradition: Hymns, Special Music, and Communion liturgies reflecting ancient beliefs.
- 10 minutes of engaging Scripture: Introduction, Readings, and liturgy that draws mostly from Scripture.
- 10 minutes of active Experience: reflecting on our salvation through prayers and each other, and sharing ways how they can work out that salvation through the announced opportunities.
All in all, a liturgical mainline worship service reflects well the four sources of authority in the United Methodist Tradition: Scripture, Reason, Tradition, and Experience. A sermon in an evangelical megachurch may include all four of those elements, but the 30 minutes of prayer and contemporary music contribute to an experience of worship but don’t often delve deeply into the other sources of authority.
Quantity or Quality…
It may seem like I’m making a “quantity or quality” argument—the megachurch may have more quantity of broadcast content, but the liturgical mainline service has more quality of content through deeper exposure to traditional liturgies and practices. Perhaps.
But in my mind, the purpose of worship is not just shaping our minds and praising God through Jesus Christ. It is to participate in the practices of the faith: the words and hymns of the ancestors, the sacraments of baptism and eucharist (and others). These traditions matter and keep us grounded in deeper ways than focusing solely on common experiences. This is the ground(ing) game, not the air war.
So I’m back to conversation with my church member: does the air war matter more than being grounded in tradition? Does more broadcast content compensate for less liturgical and traditional grounding?
The comparison may already be a lost cause. We know psychologically that corporate worship ecstasy can be “sticky” and persuasive to people moreso than participating in ancient liturgies. So while there are pockets of resurgence of participation in traditional liturgy in various traditions, psychologically speaking, it might be a losing effort.
Grounding game is about participation in ancient forms of Christianity, whereas the air war is about crowding out the broadcasts of contemporary sins. You would think they would work together–and in the best churches, they do–but there’s something about the “air war” churches that is problematic, and I think I know what.
…or Uniformity?
The argument I’m making isn’t about quantity or quality, but about the problem of a single voice being dominant in a worship service.
The “air war” minutes give a single voice ubiquity in a worship service, more than half a typical service. Given the source of the “air war” language as a hugely problematic pastor, and the multiplicity of allegations of impropriety or abuse against megachurch pastors, the problem might be that we are giving up too much of worship to one person preaching rather than a multitude (or centuries) of voices in liturgy and variety of worship music. That sort of monoculture and singularity of thought is dangerous in large quantities and over long periods of time, as we saw with Driscoll himself, and problematic in non-denominational churches without robust accountability structures.
While mainliners have their own problems, there isn’t the same uniformity of voice in worship given so much of it is given over to ancient liturgies and hymns that were written before the culture wars. Mainliners also often have far more accountability checks and balances in their bureaucratic traditions, although abuses and violations remain, there’s at least methods to hold people accountable.
By the numbers, mainline worship may be less broadcast-savvy than megachurch worship that offers more guidance to their people. But mainline worship is far less risky and more accountable, less prone to single voices leading people astray, and more likely to lead members to think for themselves about faith and life. I know I’d rather be shaped by a mainline “Jack/Jill of all trades” than a megachurch “Master of One”. But I think it comes down to preference and what environment you want your family to grow in the faith in.
Talk back in the comments!
What does your worship service look like? Take a look at the worship services that you craft or attend. Try to categorize out the elements like the above treatment.
- How much time does the church spend on broadcast messaging?
- How much on sharing and shaping experience?
- How much time attending to the traditional practices of the faith?
- Even if you aren’t United Methodist, about how much of your service is primarily about Scripture, Reason, Tradition, or Experience? Here’s an article explaining them if you need it!
Post in the comments below!
Your Turn
Thoughts?
Thanks for reading, commenting, subscribing, and sharing on social media.
I am curious about the stats for mega-churches in the mainline denomination, like the Church of the Resurrection. I am also curious about the difference between a megachurch built around a personality known for their preaching. I am a fairly middle-of-the-road preacher in talent, at least, that is my estimation of myself, an I am not sure I feel the need to preach twice as long.
I think about this at least (checks notes) once a week for the past 10 years. Good read!
I hearken back to the days before we were all on streaming media. The relative preaching time between mega churches and most mainliners was already notable. Like you, it seems to me that the mega church style has always been built around a cult of personality which invites passive acceptance of the person and message, and does not invite deeper thought and community reflection.
1)It’s kind of sad that the two options listed in the article are “mega-church” or “mainline.”
2) If you don’t like how mega-churches “do” church, build your own mega-church.
3) Are there problematic mega-churches? Absolutely. But they don’t own the market.
4) I have been a part of two mega-churches (my father grew one in the UMC and I pastored at one in the UMC) and both of them preached a very frank Gospel and were leading people into deep and transformative relationships with Jesus. You can actually have both.
5) Sermon length should be what is best for the local congregation. Personally, I preach for 30-40 minutes (I have touched 50 once. It was glorious.). My sermons are deep and drenched in Scripture. I ask a lot of my congregation in terms of challenging them with the Word of God. It works in my setting.
losing Bitcoin, Ethereum, and USDT is quite regrettable. I fell prey to an online investment schme and lossed all my money and realized it wasn’t genuine, I was hearing stories. But that wasn’t the end; I tried to contact hackers and recovery expert but was unsuccessful till I came across jamesmckaywizard a Recovery Hacker, who after 7 to 8 Hours helped me retrieve my Bitcoin. Having seen firsthand how they assisted someone in a similar circumstance, I had faith in them and was patient. Mr. James Recovery Hacker deserves praise for his excellent job. Contact them through the address below if you need a recovery expert..
Email:jamesmckaywizard at gmail dot com or what’sapp +31657446248.
To everyone who has been a victim of cryptocurrency binary investment scams currently going on right now accross the globe. I was a victim of it and I was ashamed of how I lost 807,000 Dirhams to these people pretending to be forex and binary traders. My family almost left me and I was going to lose everything until I came across a review online about jamesmckaywizard online on how he has been helping people in recovering cryptocurrency funds from these scammers. This special group of professional tech team was able to recover my money within 8hours. I’m really glad such a group exists and I’m happily sharing this out there with anyone who needs their service to recover their money. You can contact them at Email:jamesmckaywizard at gmail dot com or what’sapp ++31657446248.
I was able to reclaim my lost Bitcoin assets worth of $480,99 which i had lost to the scam company known as Capitalix fx a scam company pretending to be an investment platform which alot of people including myself have lost their funds to, sadly not all would be fortunate enough to retrieve back their funds like I did but if you’re reading this today then you’re already a step closer towards regaining your lost digital assets, Mr. James successfully retrieved back my funds in less than of 48hours after I sought for their help to get back my funds. This experience has taught me the importance of carrying out my due diligence before embracing any financial opportunity presented to me and while risk taking may be a part of the journey, some risks are not worth taking and never again will I involve myself with any online financial investment. It’s only right that we seek for external intervention and support of a higher knowledge system when it comes to digital assets recovery, Get in contact today with the team to get started on Email: jamesmckaywizard at gmail dot com or what’sapp +31657446248.
Thank you Metronet Credit Solution for helping me fix my credit score. I suffered setback on health ground that affected my credit score drastically in the year 2023. Rebuilding my credit score became a nightmare because i was already into medical collections, loans that I couldn’t pay back after my recovery in 2024, this became a very serious challenge for me, had to go online shuffling for a reputable company that could help fix my credit to no avail. On 26th of July,2025, a friend in Texas reached out to me, I complained what I was passing through, and he recommended this amazing company which I gave a shoot. I reached out to this company on 15th of August, 2025 for help,and this amazing company promised to fix my credit score after about 20mins conversation with the company, they assured to fix my credit score, delete late payments,and all negative items on my reports showing across credit bureau! Couldn’t believe it initially because it was too good to be true. Wow! to my greatest surprise, I was asked to verify and confirm my new credit score across the 3 credit bureau, and I did as directed only to see an amazing excellent credit score with all my negative items cleared, it was like a magic but then, I refused to recommend their services because I want to be very sure it was going to work out and I kept monitoring the new credit score to see if it will drop but it never dropped. Just last week Thursday, I applied for a loan from a credit firm that was into loan and got approved from same loan company that turned me down late last year. Thank you Metronet for all your help. Kindly reach via: WhatsApp or Email: METRONETCREDITSOLUTION@GMAIL.COM. Don’t forget to mention that Mr. Roger Morgan recommended their services to you.
Living a pleasant life is a blessing and some people do not want that blessing for you, so they try to steal your joy by invading your private and information but they are people who are for this kind of situation, to protect your personal information and also to get back if it gets outside, with premiumhackservices@gmail.com, it just gets better and better, Whatsapp : +14106350697 is also one of their contact line, go get back your pleasant life and be happy.
Fallen A Victim Of A Crypto Scam? – Recover Your Funds Right Now
Wassup Folks,
I genuinely hope this finds you well.
I wanted to share some wonderful news with you today: with the assistance of Seeker Assets Recovery, I just recovered my lost Crypto worth 174,000 USD that was stolen by scammers. It all started earlier last month, when I received an email from a stranger advertising a bogus Bitcoin investment opportunity. I fell for his fake promises and invested with the company. Fortunately, with the assistance of Seeker Assets Recovery, I was able to detect the fraud before it was too late. The Expert was able to retrieve the funds promptly and efficiently, and I am truly grateful for His knowledge and assistance. If you ever find yourself in a scenario like this, I highly suggest EMAIL: ( info AT seekerassetsrecovery Dot com ) WEBSITE: seekerassetsrecovery . com WHATSAPP: ( +1 (5,1,4,3,1,2,2,8,0,3 )
Best regards
In May, my credit scores were 486 (TransUnion), 514 (Equifax), and 523 (Experian). When I applied for a mortgage loan in June, I was denied due to my low FICO scores. I turned to Reddit to ask for advice on how to improve my credit. I received numerous suggestions about HACK MAVENS CREDIT SPECIALIST. I reached out to him, and he replied promptly. I shared all the details about my credit situation, but I was hesitant to release my funds to him. He assured me that he could fix my credit, and I would pay for his services once the job was completed, which I agreed to. After three days, I received a notification from Experian saying, “Congrats, your FICO Score has increased!” I quickly logged in to check, and to my surprise, he had raised my scores to 806 (TransUnion), 814 (Equifax), and 816 (Experian). All negative items on my credit report were removed; no inquiries, no collections. I’m incredibly thankful. I just received better credit card offers. H A C K M A V E N S is amazing! You can reach him via email at H A C K M A V E N S 5 AT G M A I L DOT COM or call/text/Whats-App at [+1 (2 0 9) 4 1 7 – 1 9 5 7]. Don’t forget to mention that I, Anna, referred you to him.
Beware of scammers
Beware of scammers i have been scammed 3 times because i was trying to know if my husband was cheating until i met this hacker named; “CHARLES JACOB” WEBHACKERCONSULTANT @ GMAIL COM who helped me hack into my spouse phone for real this great hacker hacked into my spouse whats-app messages,Facebook messages.text messages,call logs,deleted text messages and many more i was impressed with his job and he brought me results under 24 hours believe me he is real and his services are cheap and affordable.
I really loved and enjoyed the generosity, 100% responsive and 100% credit repair service offered me at JERRYLINK CREDIT GROUP. Hit them up for credit repair service (removal of negative items and score increase across all bureaus).They’re good recommendation because they fixed mine too which is amazing, my reports is now freed from 19 negative items and few derogatory marks and score move up by 320points. They also clear collections and charge offs. (Email:jerrylinkcreditgroup@gmail.com.. Thank me later.
GET THE BEST HACKING SERVICE‼️ contact -: Kalfjohnson424 @ gmail com.
Here Are List Of Hacking Services We Offer-:
▪️Phone Hacking & Cloning ▪️Binary Recovery, Mail Hacking ▪️Social Media hacking & recovery▪️Crypto Scam Recovery ▪️Deleted Files & Documents recovery ▪️Website Hacking ▪️Tracking using GPS and Spyware ▪️Deleted Mails and Text messages recovery.
For more enquiry, reac-h ou-t via: KalfJohnson424 @ gmail com
All Right Reserved.
When the Bible states we are gods of the earth I felt this truth during my encounter with Lord Meduza, the spell master. I’m Denzel Chau and I’m here to present the individual who transformed my life from poverty to becoming a multimillionaire Jackpot victor. I reached out to Lord Meduza for assistance with winning numbers and he successfully helped me after casting a lottery spell for me. I utilized the numbers to enter the Jackpot lottery and I was announced as the winner of $368,000,000. Acquiring the numbers from Lord Meduza took 72 hours and I want to express my gratitude publicly to him for his remarkable service to humanity and for deciding to assist me during my life’s lowest moment. Not everyone is meant to win the lottery, but with the assistance of Lord Meduza, you can achieve it. To reach him today, drop a message to his email: lordmeduzatemple@hotmail.com or Whats App +1 807 907 2687. To know more, go to his webpage: lordmeduzatemple.com and you’ll appreciate it later.
C on-tact our service.
Kalfjohnson424 @gmail com
Our List of Service.
▶️Crypto Scam Recovery
▶️Phone Hacking & Mail Hacking
▶️University Result Upgraded
➡️Social Media Hack
➡️Lost Data Recovery
➡️Private Key Reset.
For quick response.
Em -ail: kalfjohnson424 @gmail com.
DID YOU LOST YOUR CRYPTO? DO YOU WANT TO RECOVER YOUR STOLEN BITCOIN,
BEST ONLINE HACKERS
Hello guys my name is CARMEN SOTO I was happy I went online to look for a hacker because I didn’t regret it I got $187,000 from this great hackers guys am happy my family and business is back again they do various hack
BLANK ATM CARD
PAYPAL HACK TRANSFER
WESTERN UNION HACK
MONEY HACK
BITCOIN INVESTMENT
I guess I am happy I came across them. They are legit, and I am a living proof. I swear they contacted them today for your hack on their via Email address tsutomushimomurahacker@gmail.com, Or WhatsApp] +14705318087 and I’m sure you will be happy you did.
RECOVER YOUR LOST CRYPTO ASSETS WITH ASORE HACK INTELLIGENCE. NO UPFRONT PAYMENT REQUIRED.
Asore Corporation is a team of Cyber Intelligence, Crypto Investigation, Asset Tracing and Offshore Legal experts. Working together to form a boutique cyber and crypto intelligence group focused on providing results.
Using the latest Cyber Tools, Open Source Intelligence (OSINT), Human Intelligence (HUMINT), and cutting edge technology, we provide actionable intelligence to our clients.
WHY CHOOSE US?
– Expert Cyber Investigation Services —Our cyber investigators are certified in the US, UK and experienced with investigations spanning 6 continents.
– Cryptocurrency And Digital Asset Tracking — We are able to track the movement of different crypto currencies and assets. If the cryptocurrency has been moved, we are able to follow it.
– Strategic Intelligence For Asset Recovery — The first step to recovery is locating recoverable assets. Our experienced team will be able to walk you through the process.
Schedule a mail session with our team of professionals today via – asorehackcorp (@) gmail (.) com to get started immediately.
BEWARE of FABRICATED reviews and testimonies endorsing tricksters, do not get scammed twice.
Disclaimer: Asore Corporation is not a law enforcement agency and not a law firm. Like all investigators, we cannot guarantee specific results, but we apply our expertise and resources to every case professionally and ethically..
Thanks to Rewallet Shield Coin Recovery. As an entrepreneur, I’m always seeking new opportunities. Years ago, Bitcoin caught my attention, so I invested in mining equipment and accumulated Bitcoin, securely storing it with a decryption key. As my business grew, I moved on to other ventures and forgot about my Bitcoin. Recently, I checked its value and was shocked to find it worth $473,000! Excited, I tried accessing my wallet but couldn’t find the decryption key. After changing computers multiple times, it was lost. Desperate, I searched online and found Rewallet Shield Recovery, a tool designed to recover lost keys. Following its simple instructions, I let it scan my computer and external drives. After hours of processing, it provided a list of possible keys. I tested them one by one until success! I regained access to my wallet and recovered my $473,000.This experience taught me the importance of safeguarding critical information. Thanks to Rewallet Shield Recovery, I’ve recovered my assets and can reinvest in my business with confidence. Contact Email rewalletshieldcoinrecovery@aol.com WhatsApp +17573321885
I’m willing to talk about my experience investing in bitcoin. You can, however, get your stolen bitcoins back. I was taught that recovering bitcoin was impossible, therefore I never thought it was conceivable. I recently lost close to $550,000 after falling for a forex scam that promised absurdly large returns. I looked everywhere for assistance before finding a META TECH Recovery article online. When I contact META TECH Recovery, my excitement was once more total. Get in touch with META TECH Recovery as soon as possible. They are a registered hacking group that can help with a quick and efficient bitcoin recovery. Contact META TECH Recovery at:
Email: bryanpuhgehacker@gmail.com
Text message: +1 (619) 289 9154
Whatsapp: +1 (825) 585-8813
Thank You
I use to trade on a fake trading platform early this year and for a while I was gaining and making some profit. I did this trade for about 3 consecutive months and it seemed successful until my account was blocked. I had to total of 30,000usd in my account and all of it was gone in a blink. I then contacted an hacker online who helped me recover everything within only days. To my surprise all my funds was recovered and secured. I am really grateful for this.
Hacker specialist Capitalcryptorecovery @ gmail . Com.
I am Kemberly Dane from the USA . Herpes, a widespread viral infection, manifests as sores, often near the mouth or genitals. The herpes simplex virus (HSV) is the culprit, with two main types: HSV-1, linked to oral herpes (cold sores), and HSV-2, often associated with genital herpes. However, either type can affect either area. It’s important you reach out to Dr via WhatsApp +2347055029151 Email:- swordofspirit096@gmail.com for help to permanently get rid of it. He can also help you cast a love spell for someone or something you desire to have? Do you want wealth, or happiness, or a mate E.T.C. Lost lover specialist
1. We bring back lost lover
2. Do you want to win your loved one
3. We help single people to find partners
4. Do you want to be married?
5. Love attraction
6. Married problems & Divorce
8. Love potion
I want to share my experience of recovering my Bitcoin after falling victim to a scam mining bitcoin company. Like many others, I got involved with a company that seemed trustworthy at first, but eventually, I realized I had been scammed. The feeling of helplessness and frustration was overwhelming. I had invested a significant amount of $211,500USD and losing it felt like a blow to both my financial security and my trust in the crypto space. At first, I didn’t know where to turn. The feeling of being cheated left me in a state of disbelief. I tried reaching out to the company, but they stopped responding. I felt completely stuck, unsure if I would ever see my Bitcoin again. After some research, I found a recovery service (swift1@cyberservices.com or whatsapp: +1-845-224-5771) that specialized in helping people like me. I was cautious at first, not knowing if they were legitimate or just another scam. But after speaking with their team, I felt a glimmer of hope. They took the time to explain the recovery process, and they reassured me that they had experience in handling cases like mine. I wholeheartedly recommend their services. Don’t give up hope there are solutions out there, and you don’t have to navigate this journey alone. Contact swift1@cyberservices.com or WhatsApp: +1-845-224-5771
Following two unsuccessful attempts to recover my stolen USDT, I gave up on ever getting it back until Recovery Hacker101 was suggested on Quora. I was extremely happy to find the article because they were able to recover 95% of my stolen USDT, so I thought I would share it with anyone else who might be in need of their services. Their email address is recoveryhacker101 AT mail DOT com.
My names are Ruth Vivian, Am here to share a testimony on how Father Agbon helped me. After 1/5 year relationship with my boyfriend, he changed suddenly and stopped contacting me regularly, he would come up with excuses of not seeing me all the time. He stopped answering my calls and my sms and he stopped seeing me regularly. I then started catching him with different girls several times but every time he would say that he love me and that he needed some time to think about our relationship. But cannot stop thinking about him so i decided to go online and i saw so many good talk about this spell caster called Father Agbon and i contact him and explain my problems to him. He cast a love spell for me which i use and after 24 hours, my boyfriend came back to me and started contacting me regularly and we moved in together after a few months and he was more open to me than before and he started spending more time with me than his friends. We eventually got married and we now have been married happily for 3 years with a son. Ever since Father Agbon helped me, my partner is very stable, faithful and closer to me than before.You can also contact this spell caster and get your relationship fix WHATSAPP NU: +2349058797761 EmIlL: fatheragbonspellcaster@gmail.com