In the Crosshairs, at the Crossroads: Perspectives of LGBTQI Delegates
Series introduction: Given that the fate of LGBTQI people is at the center of the struggle over the future of the UMC, and that LGBTQI people represent less than 2% of the General Conference delegates (1.39%, to be exact), the experience and perspective of this group of delegates is of critical value to church leaders, other delegates, and the wider church. There can be no viable or lasting way forward that is not forged with LGBTQI people. As a small contribution to that path, this series brings you the voices of LGBTQI-identified delegates.
===
“United Methodist Church: Care for the Children”
Rev. Gregory D. Gross
The Special Called Session of General Conference will be the third GC to which I will serve as a delegate. My hope and prayer for this session is the same as the first: to amplify the voices and experiences of the young people I serve each day so others across the connection may hear from them.
My appointment as a Deacon in Full Connection is to a social service agency which seeks to provide housing, healthcare, and a human connection to those struggling with homelessness and/or poverty in Chicago. In addition to our health outreach programs, we operate a network of five shelters for homeless youth and young adults. In Chicago, more than 11,000 unaccompanied people between the ages of 14 and 24 struggle with homelessness a year. [1] Many of them face complex challenges, including those rejected because of sexual orientation or gender identity. Young people who identify as LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender) are more than twice as likely to report being homeless than their non-LGBT peers. [2]
At our low-threshold, emergency shelter for young adults aged 18-24, over half the guests each night identify as LGBTQ and over 70% are people of color. When we ask them about their experiences and why they have been living on the streets, they tell us about coming out to their families as LGBTQ. Sometimes, they have told their parents that they think they may be queer and questioning their identities. Sometimes, their parents discovered their identity. This leads to their parents telling them, “not under my roof” and kicking them out of their homes. Or their parents threaten them with violence or do beat them in hopes of changing them so the young person flees the home to protect themselves. Whichever the case, the end result is the same: a young person is alone and on the harsh streets of Chicago.
Many people say, “I live in a small, rural community and this doesn’t happen here. We don’t have homeless youth on the streets.” Yeah, you’re right. It’s because when they end up without shelter, they make their ways to the nearest city in hopes of more opportunity or at least a greater chance of blending in. We are caring for your young people.
Now, I’m often asked, “how could a parent do this to their own child?” Well, I’ve asked. The most frequent answers? “My faith tells me being gay isn’t ok.” “My church says it’s a sin.” “I can’t enable this.” “I can’t let you corrupt your siblings with these ways.”
In other words, LGBTQ youth and youth adults end up on the streets because the United Methodist Church teaches that homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching! This teaching is hurting our children. At the very least, The UMC is complicit in youth being beaten, threatened, and kicked out of their homes– if not the cause itself. Kids as young as 14 years of age.
What happens once they’re on the streets? Well, we know that 1/3 of youth are lured into prostitution within 48 hours of being on the streets? Sex work becomes a means of survival. When you’re kicked out, many times all that young people have are their selves, their bodies, so it becomes a means of income or a hot meal. Maybe you’ll even be allowed to stay the night in a warm bed.
According to a 2016 US Dept of Health and Human Services report, each month a young person is on the streets the odds of them being victimized increases by 3%. Each month. According to the study, 63% of homeless youth in Chicago have experienced at least one of the following victimizations while homeless: threatened or wounded with a weapon, robbed, beaten up, or sexually assaulted. [3]
But these aren’t just numbers. These are individuals. Children of God. In my work, I’ve sat with young people who have experienced all of this. I’ve provided support for a young woman who was raped the night before. I’ve sat with a young person who was covered in purple bruises which were the result of having been beaten by their mother. I’ve had to tell a 16 year old who had been living on the streets for the past two years that he was now HIV+. I’ve cared for these youth. I’ve cried for these youth. I now advocate for these youth.
This is why I return to General Conference. This is why I am such a passionate advocate for LGBTQ inclusion. Yes, I am gay myself. But I don’t do this work for myself. Even growing up in rural Ohio, I’ve had it relatively easy when compared to many LGBTQ people, and I know that. Yes, I’ve been threatened and have had death threats because of this advocacy. But as a Christian, it is my duty to care for the least and the last. This means LGBTQ youth. As a Deacon, my calling is to bridge the church and world. This often means bringing the message of Christ to the world. But in this case, it also means bringing the message of the world back to the church. In this case, it means: Church, stop victimizing the children. You are doing real and lasting harm.
Church, care for your children!
Endnotes:
- Chicago Coalition for the Homeless. 2016 Estimate of Homeless People in Chicago, 2018
- Morton, M. H., Samuels, G. M., Dworsky, A., & Patel, S. Missed opportunities: LGBTQ youth homelessness in America. Chicago, IL: Chapin Hall at the University of Chicago, 2018.
- Family and Youth Services Whitbeck, L., Crawford, D., Hautala, D., Welch Lazoritz, M. (2016). Administration for Children and Families Bureau Street Outreach Team: Data Collection Study Final Report.
Rev. Gregory Gross is a clergy delegate from the Northern Illinois Annual Conference to Special General Conference 2019.
Your Turn
Thoughts?
Thanks for reading, commenting, and sharing on social media. New perspectives from LGBTQI delegates 1-2x a week until the end of February here on HackingChristianity.net
Anne K Sammons
Hello Jeremy and Gregory,
Thank you, Gregory, for being a delegate @ #GC2019 and representing the LGBTQ community of the United Methodist church. #childofGod #notincompatible
Jeremy, keep up the good work.
Randi
Thank you Gregory for who your are, what you do, and sharing this story. You truly have the heart of Christ
Deb Gross
Gregory thank you for being you and all you do! I know it’s never easy but you just keep on. Know that you are loved and respected!
Jeff Jaekley
Thank you for lifting up your voice and the voices of young persons who are experiencing suffering, injustice and evil. We do need to consider the harm our words and actions cause.
I would argue that the horrible experiences these young people go through are not directly or solely caused by the church’s current stance on homosexuality. I’m not arguing for or against it, simply arguing that the harm is caused by the failure of the church to teach people that love is our highest calling and that we are to love the sinner (which is all of us) period. We are to love as Jesus loved us. There are times where Jesus told people to “go and sin no more” yet he never did so without first extending unconditional love to that person. The only people he was harsh with were the religious folk who judged without compassion and exploited those they were to serve. The church has failed in its teaching by not teaching people to love as Jesus did.
Becca Girrell
Love you, Gregory. Thank you for your powerful ministry. See you in StL.
Judy Koptik
Gregory thank you for all you do!
I wrote a long comment but an error stopped it.
Love is Love. It’s what Jesus taught us.
Let WCA go.
Bobbie Chapman
Are we called to reach out and include or to judge and exclude? Has anyone checked to see why the lost sheep was “lost” and more importantly Who left the 99 to go after it and why? Do we care about either question and if not, why not?
Mike
It’s far too late to be considering this, given the horrendous damage done by religion over millennia. The fact that anyone believes a magic, invisible fairy man in the sky will reward them for believing in him is utterly ridiculous. We expect children to outgrow their belief in Santa Claus, but we brainwash them into thinking that “god” is real. It’s disgusting.
The sooner humanity can learn to distinguish between mythology and reality, the sooner we can stop things like homophobia, misogyny, and other forms of bigotry.
Marilyn D. Kinelski
I whole heartedly agree that ALL HUMAN BEINGS are children of God!!! God has made us who we are. He has given us GRACE to uplift the spirits of all. Jesus told us not to judge!
The United Methodist Church claims that it is dedicated to “Open Hearts/OpenMinds/Open Doors.
Seems to me, that the UMC should be what it claims to be!